Where do you stand on snacking? Some people swear by snacks to keep their metabolism fired and their bodies energised. Others say that snacking leads to weight gain so its better to avoid mid-meal nibbles. Me, I’m still trying to figure it out.
In recent months it dawned on me that the weight loss part of my fitness journey is over.
This is the first time I’ve actually written that thought down and wow, it feels good! I try not to worry about weights and numbers, but when the numbers are such an obvious indicator of progress, well, what’s the harm in clinging to them just a little bit. Like Mac at Get Fit Slowly, I’m a bit of a data junkie – I was a math major, after all.
What does this have to do with snacking?
Here is a sad but undeniably true fact about weight loss: when you lose weight, you need fewer Calories to maintain it.
I graphed this phenomenon in a recent post about Calorie expenditure.
Put another way, I now have 40 lbs less of ME to feed than I did 5 years ago (damn, it takes time to lose weight). So I decided that those extra Calories I no longer need would come out of my snack budget.
For the most part, it’s been good, particularly when it comes to work productivity. And I don’t have that panicky feeling when I go out that I’m not going to be near a snack in case I start to get hungry (it helps that I still carry my emergency nuts – security in a box). I also enjoy my main meals more.
Of course, I can do all this because I’m on a schedule and I know how to plan my meals so that there aren’t any major no-eating gaps in the day. But sometimes things come up, like when a couple who are known for their spectacular cooking invites you over for dinner. Only the timing is about 4 hours after you typically eat. In these cases, there’s no sense in going hungry, because if I did, I’d scarf the meal in a hunger-induced food orgy, barely tasting a thing, and probably overeating on top of that. No, a snack is definitely called for.
This is where I found myself yesterday evening when Rory and Nina invited us over for Sri Lankan food. I knew I was going to need something to tie me get me through until dinner, but I was totally lost as to what. I definitely did not want to ruin my meal, but I also didn’t want to show up starving.
So I settled on three things: orange, carrot and avocado.
This was good, though I can’t say it was satisfying. The thing about snacks is they tend to whet my appetite for something more. Sometimes I wonder if I should just snack on something more substantial and eat less at dinner. But this is hard in eating-out situations when I’m given a plate of food and would feel rude not finishing it.
Do I think about this stuff way too much or what?
Real Simple has some ideas for healty pre-dinner snacks (“dinner’s at eight, but you just can’t wait” – I can relate!).
Jenna at Eat Live Run snacks on banana with chocolate peanut butter .
Are you a snacker? What do you eat to tide you over?
Diary for Wednesday, February 11, 2009
Swimming
Went for a short but refreshing swim first thing this morning. Swam about 600 meters in 20 minutes. Had a lane to myself until Tim showed up, probably the only person I know who I don’t mind sharing a lane with. Not that I’m Queen Bitch if someone else gets in my lane, it’s just that it’s not as nice. On the plus side, if the person I’m sharing with happens to be really fast, it often motivates me to push the envelope a bit. But not this morning. This morning was slow and easy. I missed the outdoor pool a bit – if I had been swimming outside I would have been able to watch the sun come up.
Breakfast
Bircher Muesli with Bananas and Yogurt
I have a bag of “chopped apricots” that I’m trying to get rid of. If you’re ever in the store looking for apricots and you see the pre-chopped ones and think to yourself “hey, that’ll save me time,” think again. While they may save you time, they also save you flavor! These chopped apricots are virtually tasteless compared to the juicy whole unsulphured apricots I got from Fresh and Wild. Never again.
Nevertheless, I hate wasting food. So here you have it:
1 cup oats
6 prunes
15g raisins
10g chopped apricots
20g almonds
10g flax seeds
1 apple, graded
1 lemon wedge, juiced
Walk
Two delightful laps around the park.
Lunch
Leftover sweet potato and black bean chili with a big salad and a small piece of corn on the cob
(The corn was a last minute decision and I ate it too fast to get a photo!)
Lunch made me happy. The sweet potato and black bean chili was even better the next day. I continued to look for the perfect accompanyment to balance its intense flavors. I tried avocado, but its flavor got lost in the chili so I ended up removing it and putting it on my salad. Then I tried a little bit of greek yogurt – superb! The corn was also a good move.
Snack
Orange slices, carrots and avocado
The carrot/avocado combo may seem strange, but I encourage you to try it. The avo is a great dip for carrots!
Dinner
Indian food at Rory and Nina’s
Forgive the rubishy pictures, but when I got to Nina’s and took out my camera, I realized that I forgot to replace the battery after I charged it! Sigh. So this wonderful meal was delegated to the cell phone.
The menu:
Dal
Eggplant and paneer in a coconut gravy
Shredded carrot sauteed with onion and chili
Rice with cashew nuts
Yogurt
Two bottles of San Miguel
Raspberries, jackfruit and ice cream for dessert
Everything was delicious, but the carrots were my favorite. So simple.
The jackfruit was a new experience. It had an interesting smell that was a little tough to get over. But the taste was nice, kind of like a mild pineapple.
LOLfitness says
I like to snack on hummus. Not only is it filling and great tasting, the aftertaste is so strong that it’s impossible to go on snacking on other things 🙂
monica says
Hah, I love hummus and always considered it a great snack, but I never really thought about the aftertaste effect. Hmm, makes me think I need to whip up a batch of roasted garlic hummus.
Sassy says
I usually have fruit, veggies, yogurt, or almonds as my snacks. And I almost always have a morning snack, and about 50% of the time an afternoon snack. But, I also go back and forth on snacking. Sometimes I think I should just quit snacking, because I never actually eat enough to make me not hungry, just enough so that I get something in my system so my blood sugar remains more stable. But if I eat bigger meals, I don’t snack, and generally don’t have any problems. So yeah. No good answers here.
🙂
Sassy says
okay, so I have a question for you – I just went and read your old post linked above, and was wondering why you chose the “lightly active” multiplier for your calcs? Is that to account for your 60 minutes of exercise per day?
Just curious because I always use the “sedentary” multiplier and then add in my exercise calories burned to get my numbers. And I wonder if that is causing me problems…
But then again, I never know what to classify myself as since I have a desk job, but then work out 5 days/week, so that’s why I did it that way.
Stupid numbers and formulas. I lovehate them.
Andrea [bella eats] says
I love snacks, and eat one in the afternoon every day. But I eat lunch between 12-12:30 and dinner usually isn’t until between 7-8pm. Its just too long for me to wait. A snack between 4-5pm usually keeps me satisfied. If I skip it, then when I get home at 6:30 I’m ravenous and eat anything in site, ruining my dinner and overloading my calories for the day.
Your photos are lovely today…and I’m jealous of your dinner. Really jealous. I love Indian food but never cook it, I need to go back through your archives for some recipes. For some reason I’m intimidated by it, which is silly. I read an article in Bon Appetit about how foods heavy in strong spices actually help your body to absorb less fat, while at the same time reducing the impulse to use fat (butter, oil) as a flavor enhancer in food. Strong spices also decrease our desire to eat too much because the heat builds over consumption, whereas eating an entire dish of fettucini alfredo is way too easy to do because it is so mild. Makes sense…
Sagan says
I overthink these things too 🙂 And hurray for the weight loss part of the journey being completed!
I’m a big snacker. I like to have lots of small nibbles throughout the day. My favorites are apples with peanut butter or apples with cheese. And I eat carrots when I’m in a “munching” mood.
Cammy says
Congrats on getting to your goal weight!
I’m no mathemetician, but somehow I ended up getting more calories now that I’m at goal weight. If I’m exercising vigorously, that is. When I have a few days off, I go back to my weight loss calorie range for a day or two. So far, it’s all evened out.
As far as snacking, almonds or popcorn work well for me, most of the time. If I eat fruit as a snack, I want moremoremore sugary snacks.
Evita says
I have to say that I was never a big snacker and since going optimally healthy I have refined my snacking to things like fruits and nuts. And yes some hummus with organic whole grain crisps is sometimes an option.
But nonetheless I do have to eat in between breakfast and lunch. My metabolism is very fast then and I feel I would not actually be able to continue my work each morning if I did not.
Nachos says
Sorry I’m replying to an old post -I only just discovered your blog and am reading backwards!
I love to snack! Sometimes I feel like everything I eat up till dinner time is like a snack.
I guess my eating habits might seem a little strange… I normally have a home made fresh juice or smoothie for breakfast (sometimes in two sittings if I’ve made a big serve), snack, have a mug of home made soup at about 11am, snack again, have another cup of soup at 1pm-ish, snack again… MAYBE snack one more time, then have dinner at about 6.30-7pm.
Throughout the day I normally have handful size snacks of: almonds/other raw nuts & seeds, cucumber, snow peas, corn (cut a mini cob into 2 or 3 and eat a bit every few hours), a fraction of a Larabar (sometimes these are home made!), carrot, blanched asparagus if it’s in season…
The serves are really small and just keep me going. I don’t think I could handle the idea of being stuck in a meeting all day and not being able to munch on something!
…And in case you’re wondering, my favourite way to organise this is by putting all the snacks in a child-sized bento lunch box with dividers and paper cups in it. Hmm… now that I’ve told someone my dirty snack secret, I’ve realised how OCD I must seem! LOL
Anyway – no, I don’t think you over-think it, you just want to be comfortable! Nothing worse that having a rumbling stomach for hours before going to a friend’s house for dinner… it’s like punishing yourself!