Healthy eating is a hugely popular topic, and there are loads of people out there who are praised for taking healthy eating to the mainstream. No doubt these people are doing great things by raising the awareness and the demand for “real food”. Most of us recognize that many of the nation’s health problems come down to eating processed junk and copious amounts of sugar.
I don’t eat processed junk or copious amounts of sugar. As much as I lament about my “blow outs” (fuelled largely by wine, cheese and more wine), for the most part I eat totally natural food that I make myself. And even when I’m having a “blow out”, the food is generally pretty healthy (just excessive). I also exercise every day, usually twice (once first thing in the morning and again in the afternoon), and walk as much as I can. I should be the pillar of athleticism. And yet…
Troubling symptoms
Symptom #1: In the last year my weight has increased steadily. Much of this is “good weight” – I’ve put on about 5lb of lean muscle mass (thank you CrossFit). But I’ve put on about the same amount of fat. The end result is that my favorite hiking trousers don’t fit comfortably, I don’t like what I see in the mirror and I feel constantly frustrated. I tried going back to basic principles, things that have worked in the past. As loathsome as it is, calorie counting has always been a helpful process. And so it was here, where I learned that my diet consisted of over 40% fat. Not ideal. Yeah, all that trendy healthy stuff that people think are so awesome – avocado, nuts, seeds, cold pressed oils, cacao nibs, and so on – had taken the place of loathsome carbs, resulting in an imbalanced diet and some ho hum results.
Symptom #2: Muscle fatigue. Cardio-wise I’m fine, “superb” in fact (according to my last VO2 Max test). But when it comes to anything that requires power and strength, my muscles tire very quickly. It also seems to take a while for me to recover (even after a weekend’s rest, I often find on Monday I’m still sore from the week before).
Knowing the problem ≠ Knowing the solution
Ok, I get it: I eat too many avocados, nuts, seeds and oils, and not enough complex carbohydrates. I’ve been trying to fix this for the last year, but I’ve gotten nowhere. It took me a while to realise that even though I know the problem, I don’t really know how to fix it. “Eat less fat”. But how much? And what should I eat instead? Carbs? Protein? When? How?
So I’ve decided to hire a nutritionist, which really seems like a no-brainer in retrospect. I may know a lot about “healthy food”, but I am far from a nutritionist. I also don’t know how nutrition should play into my training schedule. It seems silly now that I’ve been trying to wing it on my own, when there are qualified people just waiting to help people like me!
Hiring a Nutritionist
For the last week and a half I’ve been working with Ben Crook, the lead nutritionist at Blueberry Nutrition, who I was referred to by CrossFit Cirencester. Ben has worked with a lot of athletes, something which appealed to me. Even though I’m not competitive, I do consider myself a fairly active person and wanted a nutritionist who would take this into account. I also like Ben’s focus on science.
Ben has been working with me to create a food plan designed to achieve the following two simple objectives:
- Gain muscle and lose fat (the holy grail of fitness!)
- Increase my energy, especially during workouts
According to Ben:
The first thing to work out with any nutrition plan is – how many calories your body needs to remain at the weight you currently are. Once that has been elucidated the next step is to work out your macro-nutrient intake – Your Protein, Carbohydrate and Fat intake. It is crucial to work out your macro split in order to optimise your time in the gym. A good place to start is
- 50% Carbs
- 25% Protein
- 25% Fat
This ratio – and the number of calories I consume – will be adjusted over time to ideally stimulate healthy weight loss while increasing my energy and improving my performance at the same time.
Ben’s theory is that my lowish carb / high-fat diet means that I don’t have ideal glycogen stores, hence why I get super tired when I’m working out.
How it works
Here’s how the basic process has worked:
- I filled out a basic survey with my body weight / height stats, fitness goals, dietary requirements and foods I like / don’t like / can’t live without (Ben can tailor the plan to include things like avocado, smoothies, and even wine!)
- I had a long chat with Ben on the phone to talk more about my goals and what I’d like from my nutrition plan
- After Ben sent me the first food plan, we had another chat to talk it over and discuss any tweaks I wanted to make.
- Ben has just sent me my second week food plan, which we’re again going to tweak a little. Ben has been really amazing with his communication and response to all of my incessant queries!
A few random thoughts so far
- For the most part, each meal on the food plan consists of a list of food (e.g. “Edamame beans 200g, Watercress 20g, Beetroot 40g, Pumpking Seeds 16g”), so it takes some creativity to figure out what to do sometimes. A few of the meals include pre-defined recipes, which so far have been pretty tasty (see the recipe for the pistachio orange salmon below which I totally love)
- The plan involves a lot of snacks, which I’m learning to love, particularly Nairns Oat Cakes!
- There have been occasional meals where I feel like I’m “eating nutrients” rather than a cohesive meal. Those were a downer.
- I’ve had to change up my smoothies, which has been a revelation – instead of avocado, I’ve been using oats and Naturya chia seeds (it doesn’t take much) to thicken my smoothies. It’s pretty great!
- I’ve been enjoying savoury breakfasts again – on alternate days, I have scrambled eggs, which are particularly good with homemade sauerkraut!
- I’m eating a lot of fish.
- I’ve been getting through a lot of barley.
- The plan calls for post-workout protein shakes. Until now I’ve shirked the idea of taking “supplements”, but I’m willing to give this a go, if only as an experiment. I haven’t started this yet as I’m still waiting for my protein powder order to arrive (I’m using the Impact Whey Protein Isolate from myprotein.com which I’ve used in the past and consider pretty good as far as protein powder goes). I’ve tried hemp and pea protein but found them intolerable unless mixed with juice, not ideal as I’m trying to keep the post-workout shake purely protein. Any tips are welcome!
How do I feel?
There are some recipes that I really miss – my favourite dal and red lentil soup come to mind. But I know it’s not forever. This is a learning process – I have to learn what “balance” really means! And contrary to popular media, “balanced” doesn’t necessarily mean putting cold pressed olive oil and pistachios and avocado and cacao nibs on all of the things!
It’s early days and it’s really too soon to say whether this nutrition plan is working. There have been days when I’ve felt totally shattered, but then again, this has been a very mentally taxing week so I’m sure that’s played a role.
In general, I actually feel pretty good. I’m definitely more motivated to push myself a little harder and see what I can do, which probably has less to do with my diet change and more to do with the mental boost that all of us get when we do something good for ourselves. In fact, when you put it that way, the nutrition plan has already proved successful. This is a state of mind I have to work at; it’s all too easy to be impatient and disappointed. I think it’s time to redefine “success”. Success isn’t about reaching an objective (that’s a “goal”). Taking action is success, and any one of us who are taking steps to reach our goals are already inherently successful. Go us!
More to come as the nutrition plan experiment progresses. In the meantime, here’s that awesome salmon recipe I mentioned…
Pistachio Salmon Fillets
Serves 4
Ingredients
- 4 salmon fillets
- ½ Cup of Shelled pistachios – crushed
- 4 Tsps. Dijon mustard
- 1Tbsp. Orange juice
- 2 tsp. Orange zest
- ¼ tsp. salt
- ½ tsp. Pepper
- ½ Cup chopped spring onions
Method
- Put crushed pistachios into a shallow dish
- Mix mustard, orange zest, orange juice, salt and pepper into a bowl
- Brush the mixture onto each of the flesh of each salmon fillets.
- Press salmon into pistahios
- Place fillets onto baking tray and bake at 180°C for around 10-20 mins, until cooked through
- Place onions onto baking tray and drizzle with oil.
- Grill onions for a couple of minutes until they start to wilt
- Serve onions with salmon fillets
Per serving: 370 Kcal | 15g Fat | 9g Carbs | 39g Protein
Related links:
- Blueberry Nutrition [blueberry-nutrition.co.uk]
- 2015 CrossFit Goals
- 2015 Adventure Goals
nazima says
Great post Monica – and appreciate your insights. We can all get caught up with so called ‘superfoods’ and forget the important idea of balancing the nutrients. Love the salmon recipe and will be trying it out
Monica says
Thanks, Nazima – let me know what you think of the recipe!
Dhiren says
It’s good that you’ve got some sound advice. It’s sad that you think carbs are ‘loathsome’. I think a whole raft of fashionable diets – all clinically unsound – have demonsied carbs and put people on the wrong track when it comes to balanced long-term nutrition. Also, the fitness industry makes people believe that it’s normal to maintain low body-fat all year round, but the truth is that it’s very unrealistic for most people who are not naturally(genetically) lean. These unrealistic aspirations then cause unhealthy relationships with food, knee-jerk diet experimentation and low self-confidence.
In the real world – not the world of selfies and magazine covers – even pro athletes do not maintain low body fat percentages all year round, but the media and their sponsors don’t show these pictures. I mean, how would the supplements industry make any money 😉
I too have a nutritionist. For my sport, I now know what the rules are and I’m aware when I’m breaking them. Professional advice has actually helped me to be less pedantic. I now eat without guilt to fuel and recover from training and, as for weight loss, I know that effort translates into performance results and aesthetics are just the icing on the cake. I don’t eat and train to be lean. I eat and train for better competence in a sport that I enjoy. One day, if a perform like a athlete, I might look like one and that’s frame of mind I’m comfortable with.
Monica says
Thanks for the comment, Dhiren. You’ve offered some very welcome reassurance. It’s oh so good to be back on the happy carb track. 🙂
Janice Tissington says
Hi Monica,
The salmon recipe sounds amazing, I will be trying it very soon.
I really enjoyed reading your comments regarding nutrition. I too have followed a low complex carb and healthy diet for most of the last year whilst excercing much more. Cooking from scratch and eating more nuts, seeds and healthy fats. I avoid bread as this is my trigger food to eat unhealthily. Luckily I don’t find I want to drink alcohol much anymore.
I have a personal trainer who has helped me with strength training and cardio. I am now in the best shape I have ever been in my adult life and the lowest weight too, but I too have started to struggle with the harder training sessions (I am currently training for my first half marathon) especially the longer runs. Being muscle sore and tired days after workouts, I was starting to think I was over training but I hadn’t considered my calorie intake. My trainer keeps asking me whether I am eating enough carbs and food in general. I thought I was, but it may be that I’m not, it’s very hard when you have been overweight all of your life to get your head around eating more food when you still want to lose weight. I know I have good levels of lean muscle and much lower body fat than ever before but I feel I need to reassess my ‘ healthy diet’ and I have you to thank for bringing this to my attention.
Many thanks
Janice
Janice Tissington says
Sorry, forgot to mention that I also now add oats to my smoothies to up my carb intake and have tried my first protein shake after my long run on Sunday, I too have avoided these at all costs as I didn’t want to take supplements or have the sweeteners added to most, but I have to say it really helped, I had no sore muscles after running 8 miles for the first time ever! So I will look into the website you mentioned as I hated the taste of the protein powder I tried.
Thanks again